I don't have time for "private languages" since the public ones are hard enough.

However, I once published some when my little friend Rusty died. And I think the collages Rachel assembled to illustrate some of them are spectacular.

During the 19 years I was with him, Paul introduced me to Edna St. Vincent Millay, among many other authors, whose poems he would always recite by heart. Most of her rhymes seem pretty tame today, but I still like some of it:

Love is not all; . . .
Love can not fill the thickened lung with breath,
Nor clean the blood, nor set the fractured bone;
Yet many a man is making friends with death
Even as I speak, for lack of love alone.
[Sonnet XXX from Fatal Interview, 1923]
Down, down, down into the darkness of the grave
Gently they go, the beautiful, the tender, the kind.
Quietly they go, the intelligent, the witty, the brave.
I know. But I do not approve. And I am not resigned.
[Dirge Without Music, 1928]
There is no God.
But it does not matter.
Man is enough.
["Conversation at Midnight", 1937]

In our age of political correctness, superior people are supposed to apologize for being gifted. But she never agreed:

Country of hunchbacks!
-- where the strong, straight spine,
Jeered at by crooked children, makes his way
Through by-streets at the kindest hour of day,
Till he deplore his stature, and incline
To measure manhood with a gibbous line;
Till out of loneliness, being flawed with clay,
He stoop into his neighbor's house and say,
"Your roof is low for me -- the fault is mine"
Dust in an urn long since, dispersed and dead
Is great Apollo; and the happier he;
Since who amongst you all would lift a head
At a god's radiance on the mean door tree,
Saving to run and hide your dates and bread,
And cluck your children in about your knee?
["Sonnet to Gath"]

When Inez Milholland died, Edna said:

Upon this marble bust that is not I
Lay the round, formal wreath that is not fame;
But in the forum of my silenced cry
Root ye the living tree whose sap is flame.
I, that was proud and valiant, am no more; ---
Save as a dream that wanders wide and late,
Save as a wind that rattles the stout door,
Troubling the ashes in the sheltered grate.
The stone will perish; I shall be twice dust.
Only my standard on a taken hill
Can cheat the mildew and the red-brown rust
And make immortal my adventurous will.
Even now the silk is tugging at the staff:
Take up the song; forget the epitaph.
["To Inez Milholland", read in Washington, November
eighteenth, 1923, at the unveiling of a statue of
three leaders in the cause of Equal Rights for Women.]

To which I would only add that it's a symphony, not a song. We each have something different to contribute.

Check out this similar poem, by Amelie Josephine Burr. I reprinted it in the Journal when Paul died, and in 2009 Rachel assembled a for it.

But when it comes to death, this poem by Mary Elizabeth Frye kind of says it all, and especially what I want people to know about me when I go away:

Do not stand at my grave and weep
I am not there. I do not sleep.
I am a thousand winds that blow.
I am the diamond glints on snow.
I am the sunlight on ripened grain.
I am the gentle autumn rain.
When you awaken in the morning's hush
I am the swift uplifting rush
Of quiet birds in circled flight.
I am the soft stars that shine at night.
Do not stand at my grave and cry;
I am not there. I did not die.

Since Mary never copyrighted it, it was copied hand to hand, and so there are lots of variations around. The above version is from .

When I die I don't want to be buried, and I don't see the point of being cremated. Ever since I was a little boy I've wanted to be fed to the lions at the Bronx Zoo.

See to it. If you really insist on categorizing limmericks as poetry, then I have to admit a fondness for what I call "fairy limmericks". If chess with weird pieces can be termed "fairy chess", then I guess "fairy limmericks" might include self-referentials and limmericks that rebel from strict form. On the other hand, I really, really hate Joyce Kilmer's "Trees". Not because it's a bad poem, mind you, but only because bad schoolteachers made us listen to it over and over again until we wanted to throw up, each time expecting us to swoon in delight — and expressing disappointment and disapproval when we didn't. Ironically, this also made them glow with pride because it confirmed their suspicion that we were all just a ragged bunch of street urchins compared to them. I got over what they did to Shakespeare, but not what they did to Kilmer. I got to make fun of that bad memory when a friend of mine was given a retirement luncheon and I got to read a tribute to him consisting of the same only too-familiar rhyme meter but with Joyce's sacharine words replaced by funny jibes. Okay, sometimes I like funny poems, especially Tuli Kupferberg's "Nothing", which was put to music by my friend Richard Shulberg (aka "Citizen Kafka", 1947 - 2009) and performed often by his Wretched Refuse String Band:

Monday: Nothing,
Tuesday: Nothing,
Wednesday and Thursday: Nothing.
Friday, for a change: A little more nothing,
Saturday: Once more nothing.

Sunday: Nothing,
Monday: Nothing,
Tuesday and Wednesday: Nothing.
Thursday, for a change: A little more nothing,
Friday: Once more nothing.

Montik: Gornicht,
Dinstik: Gornicht,
Midwoch an Donnerstik: Gornicht.
Fritik, far a noveneh: Gornicht pikveleh,
Shabas: Nach a mool gornicht.

Lunes: Nada,
Martes: Nada,
Miercoles y Jueves: Nada.
Viernes, por cambio: Poco mas nada,
Sabado: Otra vez nada.

January: Nothing,
February: Nothing,
March and April: Nothing.
May and June: A lot more nothing,
Ju-uly: Nothing.

'29: Nothing,
'32: Nothing,
'39-'45: Nothing.
1965: A whole lot of nothing,
1966: Nothing.

Reading: Nothing,
Writing: Nothing,
Even arithmetic: Nothing.
Geography, philosopy, history, nothing,
Social anthropology (hakalakala): Nothing.

Oh, "Village Voice": Nothing,
"New Yorker": Nothing,
"Sing Out" and "Folkways": Nothing.
Harry Smith and Allen Ginsberg:
Nothing, nothing, nothing.

Poetry: Nothing,
Music: Nothing,
Painting and Dancing: Nothing.
The world's great books: A great set of nothing,
Audy and Foudy: Nothing.

F*cking: Nothing,
Sucking: Nothing,
Flesh and sex: Nothing.
Church and Times Square: A lot of nothing,
Nothing, nothing, nothing.

Stevenson: Nothing,
Humphry: Nothing,
Averell Harriman: Nothing.
John Stuart Mill: Nihil, nil.
Franklin Delano Nothing.

Karlos Marx: Nothing,
Engels: Nothing,
Bukunin and Krapotkin: Nyothing.
Leon-a Trotsky: Lots of nothing,
Stalin: Less than nothing.

Nothing! Nothing! etc.
(Lots & lots of nothing)
Nothing! Nothing! etc.
(Lots of it)
Nothing!
(Not a God damn thing)