On Cats and Sadness and What We Owe to the Dead
The Paul Rosenfels Community
Social Progress
through Personal Growth

On Cats and Sadness and What We Owe to the Dead

My boyfriend gave me an assignment today — to read an Archy and Mehitabel story

animal liberation

 

Rachel Bartlett is an inde­pen­dent scholar who grew up in East Germany and pur­sued English and American studies, political science and modern history at Humboldt Un­i­ver­sity in Berlin. She read all of Paul Rosenfels' pub­lished works in 1999. Since 2007 she has con­tributed to our website 84 new pages, translated 44 of our pages into German, and assembled 64 beauti­ful and relevant collages that decorate 51 separate pages. In 2011 she moved to Manhattan and, a year later, pub­lished It's Simple! Ordinary common-sense explanations for everything you haven't figured out yet. In 2016 she founded the Science of Human Nature blog. Rachel can be reached at http://www.rachel-bartlett.com .

My boyfriend gave me an assigment today — to read an Archy and Mehitabel story. 1 

Don Marquis was obviously using his characters — Archy, a giant cockroach who is friends with Mehitabel, a cat — to portray human types, not animals. Mehitabel laments having had babies instead of a "high life".

Real cats, of course, don't suffer when they are caring for kittens, and they don't "sacrifice" anything. They know how to take care of themselves, unlike humans who often either neglect themselves, or their kids. If a cat is hungry, she will go hunt and eat, and not get worried to death about her kittens being alone for a while and getting so psychologically damaged they will need therapy when they grow up.

Like Mehitabel, my grandma would have loved to not have children, or not so many, and she would have loved to learn and be a nurse. She felt inferiour for being uneducated — as a child under the Nazi regime, she had been allowed to attend school for four years only, and then she got crushed by having six children, and never found the courage to just say, "Fuck you all, for the next hour, I am going to read a book!"

She even felt guilty when she gave one of her children to her sister who couldn't have children. She needed to be told that this was a wonderful thing to do! After all, her daughter was still hanging out with her siblings, she was not suffering from hunger, had good parents, and later inherited their house and farm. My grandma's sister got the child she wanted, and my grandma had one hungry mouth less to feed. These were very lucky circumstances — the proverbial good luck hidden in bad luck — if you have the courage to look at them the right way, and say goodbye to traditional concepts about what it means to be a good mother and sacrifice yourself for a silly idea.

When I was studying history and literature, I fell ill with university victimization by proxy — over-identifying with the victim aspect of everything. I was so obviously shaken by the mistreatment of large sections of the medieval society that a friend said to me, "All those people who died on the pyre in 1349 would be dead by now anyway". That is very smart — I just wish she had added, "Care for the living instead, dufus!" That is something I needed to be told!

I did feel sad when my grandma died because I was still single then, and I would have loved her to meet my children and my boyfriend. But in the end, it is better I have my own life and not repeat her mistakes, just as it would be utterly pointless to go out and seek revenge for a witch or a Jew who were burnt to death in 1349. People have suffered so much, for all the wrong reasons. To be unhappy over what happened centuries ago would be wrong and selfish — in a bad way, as this is not helping anybody, including the noble person who decides to suffer.

We all feel sad at times that we didn't give more. But often giving more would have meant turning away from the growth process and betraying humanity. Everything important that my grandma could possibly pass on is still alive in me, and everything I wish I could have given her I can give any person I deem worth it.

The new paradigm will no longer be "giving back" but "giving forward". You never really repay your teachers except by helping the next generation.

— Dean Hannotte

© 2010 Rachel Bartlett
See more of Rachel's collages
Notes
 1 mehitabel and her kittens , from archy and mehitabel , by Don Marquis, 1927:
well boss
mehitabel the cat
has reappeared in her old
haunts with a
flock of kittens
three of them this time

archy she says to me
yesterday
the life of a female
artist is continually
hampered what in hell
have i done to deserve
all these kittens
i look back on my life
and it seems to me to be
just one damned kitten
after another
i am a dancer archy
and my only prayer
is to be allowed
to give my best to my art
but just as i feel
that i am succeeding
in my life work
along comes another batch
of these damned kittens
it is not archy
that i am shy on mother love
god knows i care for
the sweet little things
curse them
but am i never to be allowed
to live my own life
i have purposely avoided
matrimony in the interests
of the higher life
but i might just
as well have been a domestic
slave for all the freedom
i have gained
i hope none of them
gets run over by
an automobile
my heart would bleed
if anything happened
to them and i found it out
but it isn t fair archy
it isn t fair
these damned tom cats have all
the fun and freedom
if i was like some of these
green eyed feline vamps i know
i would simply walk out on the
bunch of them and
let them shift for themselves
but i am not that kind
archy i am full of mother love
my kindness has always
been my curse
a tender heart is the cross i bear
self sacrifice always and forever
is my motto damn them
i will make a home
for the sweet innocent
little things
unless of course providence
in his wisdom should remove
them they are living
just now in an abandoned
garbage can just behind
a made over stable in greenwich
village and if it rained
into the can before i could
get back and rescue them
i am afraid the little
dears might drown
it makes me shudder just
to think of it
of course if i were a family cat
they would probably
be drowned anyhow
sometimes i think
the kinder thing would be
for me to carry the
sweet little things
over to the river
and drop them in myself
but a mother s love archy
is so unreasonable
something always prevents me
these terrible
conflicts are always
presenting themselves
to the artist
the eternal struggle
between art and life archy
is something fierce
my what a dramatic life i have lived
one moment up the next
moment down again
but always gay archy always gay
and always the lady too
in spite of hell
well boss it will
be interesting to note
just how mehitabel
works out her present problem
a dark mystery still broods
over the manner
in which the former
family of three kittens
disappeared
one day she was taking to me
of the kittens
and the next day when i asked
her about them
she said innocently
what kittens
interrogation point
and that was all
i could ever get out
of her on the subject
we had a heavy rain
right after she spoke to me
but probably that garbage can
leaks so the kittens
have not yet
been drowned

archy

Here is a German-language version of this page
[Hier ist eine deutsche Version dieser Seite]

Über Katzen und Traurigsein und was wir den Toten schuldig sind  E 

Recently Visited Page

On Cats and Sadness and What We Owe to the Dead  G 

My boyfriend gave me an assignment today — to read an Archy and Mehitabel story

Rachel's Essays

And Here There be Nazis!
Can I Take Your Picture?
Censorship is back! Now new and improved!
Female Bonding
Get Your Heart Broken Every Once in a While

I recently wrote an essay to help a girl who had led me to believe she needed some help, encouragement, and guidance. Believing she had escaped the open air gulag that is North Korea, I was pretty shaken and reminded of the damage that life in Stasi-controlled East Germany had done to me and my people

Graduating from the Ninth Street Center [2008]

The Ninth Street Center seemed like a good idea in 1973 . . . and maybe it was

How I Happened To Myself [memoir]

On the evening of May 4th 2007, I found a stack of letters. I couldn't tell whether they were meant for me — they were addressed to a Rachel

How to be an Important Earthling
Human Nature and the Coming Crisis, Part 1

The first and most important belief I hold is that humans are inherently good

Human Nature and the Coming Crisis, Part 2

Just keep in mind that we usually create a better world not in spectacular catastrophic situations like plane crashes, but in rather simple circumstances

In Praise of Leafy Therapists: Hail the Great Books of Western Civilization   
In the Pressure Cooker

New York is a pressure cooker for human development; this city will make or break you. I don't know what it is that makes some people break, and others grow and bloom. How come some have to just leave this place?

Is Timothy Going to be Alright?

Yesterday, while I was trying to restore data from a borked SD card, a tiny, sick mouse stumbled into my life

It is Never Too Late to Have a Good Childhood

Go buy that stuffed animal or that train set you are secretly craving!

Jonestown v. The East Village
My Article about Paul Rosenfels in Wikipedia [2008]
Observations of a Supposed Former Investigative Journalist   
On Experiments in Human Nature, and the Nature of our World  G 

The one experiment in human nature that impresses me more than anything any professional psychologist ever came up with is the Free Hugs campaign

On Joy and Exclamation Marks

Meow! Meow! Anything on up to four legs that barks is a dog!

Socialism and Human Nature
Stolen Valor
The Ground Zero Flag

One of the fun things to do in New York in September is going to The Feast de San Gennaro in Little Italy. It helps if you have seen the Godfather movies

The Personal is the Psychological

One of the fun things to do in New York in September is going to The Feast de San Gennaro in Little Italy. It helps if you have seen the Godfather movies

The Pursuit of Happiness

I was born into a giant work camp. In general, you were raised to work as hard as you can ("from each according to his abilities"), only enjoy what was justifiable ("to each according to his needs"), and not ask questions. Guess who determined what your abilities and needs were?

To my Friends in Germany who have been Betrayed by their Repre­sent­atives
What the Confederate Flag Means to Me
Why Good People do Bad Things

Do you actually do good in the world, or are you merely very, very convinced of your own good intentions?

Why We Need Paul Rosenfels  G 

Question: If polarity is just the way humans are, why do we need to study it? The short answer: For the same reason we need to know about gravity

Format:   desktop    mobile    printer   

     
     

The Paul Rosenfels Community  G   G    © 1997-2025 Rachel Bartlett

Formerly All content by Dean Hannotte except where otherwise noted. Subscribe to our RSS feed . Statistics by Site Meter.

Locations of visitors to this page

Write to us at dean@hannotte.com. Join The Age of Enlightenment Book Club. This page was published on February 13, 2010 and last modified on March 1, 2017.

Truth is a work in progress. We like our diamonds rough.
Leave your guns, your umbrellas, and your citations at the door.